![]() |
| LinkBack | Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
|
# 21
02-24-2010
man doc, you really seem to be anti supplement. Sorry bro, but its your industry who finds it better to treat peoples symptoms rather than cure them. Keeping people sick is good money for you bros.
My trust for the medical community VERY low. from very personal experience.
# 23
02-24-2010
|
My trust for the medical community VERY low. from very personal experience.
|
Or think of it this way: Would it be fair to judge the entire supplement community based on what MuscleTech does?
Lou
# 24
02-24-2010
Its not just my experiences, multiple, its based on the systems on which they act. and no... its not every healthcare provider. But the system in general. there are some providers out there who care about the patients, but a sad majority care about their income first. The pharmaceutical companies who give them nice bonuses for prescribing the latest medication, without regard for the fact that prescribing a Zpack for a simple infection might not be the best course of treatment and its better to start with the basics... you know, so as to prevent Antibiotic resistance? or treating symptoms because as i said... big pharma makes more money off of you being chronically ill than they do keeping you healthy. Its just good business... but bad practice.
# 25
02-24-2010
|
Where's the large multi-center clinical trials proving that claim? I want to see solid clinical evidence with thousands of patients enrolled demonstrating that any naturopathic treatment for CAD is as or more effective than aggressive statin therapy. Guess what: you won't find any. Remember, the US supplement industry is worth many billions of dollars annually... so the excuse that "there's no money" in doing such research is complete bullshit.
I have CAD, was probably months away from having a fatal MI due to left main disease, and required an emergency CABG. There's no friggin' way I'd now take pomegranate extract or any other "natural supplements" in lieu of agents that are far more potent and have a proven track record of reducing cardiovascular events and regressing plaques. Needless to say, if you did your research, you'd also realize that statins are naturally occurring substances. True, the latest generation of statins are synthetic or semi-synthetic, but structurally they're all in the same class. I've said this before, and I'll say it again: from the body's perspective, medications, supplements and foodstuffs are all just chemicals interacting with various biochemical pathways. The body doesn't know whether you've taken something squeezed out of a fruit or made synthetically. There's nothing inherently "better" about "natural" substances, and in fact some of the most toxic compounds known to man are naturally occurring. - Dan |
if supplements didn't work for such things as blood pressure, cholesterol, heart health etc.... why do so many bodybuilders take them, ie... howthorne berry, celery seed extract, red yeast rice, pomagranite extract, ....., cause they work.
# 27
02-24-2010
Dan is probably saying that 1 reason because there are so many kids out there purchasing this stuff, not doing any research then having to go to the dr and make them fix the problem. research is a must before doing any type of sup, but many chose not to
robert
# 28
02-24-2010
|
I was referring to many of the comments he makes about them and the industry. Saying "no solid studies have been done on this" when yes... yes they have. Or saying they should be more regulated... cause you know.. thats just what you need... or can you just not wait for the day you have to go to the doctor to get some DHEA, and it cost you $250 for a months supply if you dont have insurance.
Dan is probably saying that 1 reason because there are so many kids out there purchasing this stuff, not doing any research then having to go to the dr and make them fix the problem. research is a must before doing any type of sup, but many chose not to robert |
Originally Posted by believer
If you don't know how to get SERMS, you haven't been around long enough and probably aren't ready to do a cycle of Superdrone..
...and people wonder why I advocate the notion of medically supervised performance enhancement.
- Dan
I don't see where this statement includes every supplement for sale OTC.
# 29
02-24-2010
|
You want studies on pomagranite, google them, there are literally tons of humans studies done. Even are very own Primordial performance did an article on it. Speaking of cholesterol, there was a study done, which showed, RED Yeast rice worked better or equal to any cholesterol lowering statin.
if supplements didn't work for such things as blood pressure, cholesterol, heart health etc.... why do so many bodybuilders take them, ie... howthorne berry, celery seed extract, red yeast rice, pomagranite extract, ....., cause they work. |
- Dan
# 30
02-24-2010
I never said that pomegranate juice does nothing; what I said is that there are no head-to-head studies which show that pomegranate juice is equivalent or superior to statins in terms of cardiovascular endpoints. Until such research is done, the standard of care is statin therapy. That's the way evidence-based treatment works in medicine.
- Dan
# 31
02-24-2010
|
None of the studies you cited shows equivalency or superiority of pomegranate juice or extract to statin therapy.
I never said that pomegranate juice does nothing; what I said is that there are no head-to-head studies which show that pomegranate juice is equivalent or superior to statins in terms of cardiovascular endpoints. Until such research is done, the standard of care is statin therapy. That's the way evidence-based treatment works in medicine. - Dan |
# 32
02-24-2010
# 33
02-24-2010
|
None of the studies you cited shows equivalency or superiority of pomegranate juice or extract to statin therapy.
I never said that pomegranate juice does nothing; what I said is that there are no head-to-head studies which show that pomegranate juice is equivalent or superior to statins in terms of cardiovascular endpoints. Until such research is done, the standard of care is statin therapy. That's the way evidence-based treatment works in medicine. - Dan |
# 34
02-24-2010
|
Dan is probably saying that 1 reason because there are so many kids out there purchasing this stuff, not doing any research then having to go to the dr and make them fix the problem. research is a must before doing any type of sup, but many chose not to
|
However, I think eventually there is going to be a legal redefinition of what constitutes a "nutritional supplement" in the US. Let's face it, it's really hard to argue that PHs and DSs fit into that category. I'm not saying that I approve of such a change per se, but rather that it is not going to surprise me if and when it happens.
- Dan
# 35
02-24-2010
|
Maybe because they don't have access to those prescription medications, or don't feel like paying for them. Quite frankly, I don't give a shit what bodybuilders use or don't use; I'm talking about clinical trials with extremely large numbers of patients enrolled which show a definite benefit of certain medications. Why the hell should I take hawthorn berry extract, RYR, etc. when I have access to REAL medications that are pharmaceutical grade, of precise dosages, have tons of studies behind them, and are known to work very well?
- Dan |
and to be fair... and yes some of the things we take can have bad sides (i.e. our pro-steroids, which we only take for the most part because of the legal hassle in the old versions) but as far as the actually natural stuff like C0Q10, hawthorn etc, if both are effective i would rather take them than a pharma grade chemical that will have worse sides.
as far as red yeast rice "in 2001 red yeast rice extract, a "natural" unregulated nutritional supplement was withdrawn by the FDA when it was determined that red yeast rice supplements were too similar in chemical structure to the strictly regulated prescription statin known as Mevocor. In fact, red yeast rice is almost identical to lovastatin, which is the key ingredient in the statin drug Mevacor."
Which is a reason i dont use it unless needed... and then in low doses for short periods... they have the same sides
The Major Side Effects of Statin Drugs
Nausea
Irritability and short tempers
Hostility
Homicidal impulses
Rapid loss of mental clarity
Amnesia
Kidney failure
Diarrhea
Muscle aching and weakness
Tingling or cramping in the legs
Inability to walk
Problems sleeping
Constipation
Impaired muscle formation
Erectile dysfunction
Temperature regulation problems
Nerve damage
Mental confusion
Liver damage and abnormalities
Neuropathy
Destruction of CoQ10, a vital nutrient for health
RYR:
Headache
Indigestion
Bloating and gas
Dizziness
Heartburn
Muscle pain
Joint pain
Liver inflammation
Damage to peripheral nerves
now in comparison...
Hawthorne:
transient cases of
mild rash,
headache,
sweating,
dizziness,
sleepiness,
agitation,
and gastrointestinal symptoms
CoQ10
transient cases of
rashes,
nausea,
upper abdominal pain,
dizziness,
sensitivity to light,
irritability,
headache,
heartburn,
and fatigue.
Policosanol:
is well tolerated and safe in a study of 4596 patients. No serious adverse nor side effects were reported
Lets also note that if i go to the hospital for cholestasis... they are going to give me NAC, which i have a big bulk bad of in my kitchen
# 36
02-24-2010
|
lets say both statins and supplements work pretty much equal. getting a prescription is a big pain in the ass. you have to make time to see a dr. he writes the prescription, you'd think he'd just write a prescription that lasts. of course not, every few months it runs out. and the dr wants to see you again. forget that. id much rather not depend on dr's and the government for my things. getting supplements is like getting a gallon of milk. thats how i like it. fast and simple.
|
As far as refills of prescriptions, that depends on your doctor. My cardiologist writes me for three month supplies of all my meds with three refills, i.e. an entire year, even though I see him every 3-4 months. Same thing for my urologist and the Androgel.
- Dan
# 37
02-24-2010
|
If I recall correct... in order to perform a proper clinical study on an existing drug you need permission of the drug company and the FDA. Not going to happen in this case, they would have too much to lose....
|
- Dan
# 38
02-24-2010
|
but there have been clinical trials on these.
and to be fair... and yes some of the things we take can have bad sides (i.e. our pro-steroids, which we only take for the most part because of the legal hassle in the old versions) but as far as the actually natural stuff like C0Q10, hawthorn etc, if both are effective i would rather take them than a pharma grade chemical that will have worse sides. |
- Dan
![]() |
| Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Posting Rules
|
|






